Cat In The Cabernet
TASTING NOTES: A mystery! A Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon or Cabernet Sauvignon Red Blend, each with a retail value of $100 or more.
VARIETALS: Cabernet Sauvignon Red Blend or Cabernet Sauvignon
THAT REMINDS ME OF: Mystery Reds, the name of this offer, and the fact that almost every language has a proverb warning you not to buy one.
In English you’re told not to buy a pig in a poke (“poke” is an old word for a bag, same root as “pocket”). The popular story is that a market swindler would sell you a suckling pig in a sack, you’d get home, and the thing you’d paid for turned out to be a cat. You let the cat out of the bag, and the scam is over. Etymologists are skeptical of that tidy origin, but the proverb is old. The Germans say die Katze im Sack kaufen, buying the cat in the sack. The French say acheter chat en poche. Spanish goes with dar gato por liebre, “to hand over a cat instead of a hare,” which skips the bag and gets straight to the insult. Same crime every time, and the animal changes with the local market.
What I love is that every one of those proverbs is a warning about a swindler, and a mystery bottle has no swindler in it. It has a sealed box, a $100-and-up retail value, and a Napa Valley address. The only cat here is the one my brain keeps trying to put in the box. I’d like to know which animal Schrödinger would have picked if he’d been a wine person (I assume the cat is a Cabernet).